Crime

Stoppage Of EFCC’s Probe On N1.8bn Subsidy Fraud: S’Court Dismisses Yanaty’s Appeal

217

By Amos Dunia, Persecond News

Abuja – The Supreme Court on Friday, dismissed the appeal filed by Yanaty Petrochemical Limited that sought to set aside the decision of the Court of Appeal, Abuja Division allowing the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), to continue investigation and prosecution of the company over an alleged N1.8billion petroleum subsidy fraud.

Crisis for Yanaty started when Elias Adeojo, Managing Director of Yanaty Petrochemical Limited, got approval by the Petroleum Products Pricing Regulatory Agency (PPRA), to import 30,000 tons of Premium Motor Spirit (PMS), under the Petroleum Support Scheme in the first quarter of 2011.

The company claimed that it imported 31, 256.992 metric tons in March, 2011 via MT Beaver and purportedly discharged the product at Lister Oil Jetty, Lagos, managed by Oando Marketing Plc.

As a result, Yanaty allegedly received N2, 731, 942, 103.73 for purportedly discharging 42, 773, 279million litres of PMS.

But investigation showed that Oando, being operator of Lister Jetty, disclosed that MT Beaver discharged only 10, 187.353 metric tons, of PMS for Yanaty, as against the 31, 256.992 it claimed to have discharged.
Based on the foregoing. Yanaty, allegedly received N1, 840, 768, 720 (One Billion, Eight Hundred and Forty Million, Seven Hundred and Sixty-Eight Thousand, Seven Hundred and Twenty Naira) as unearned subsidy from the Federal Government.

However, in a bid to prevent further investigation into the alleged subsidy fraud, Yanaty approached and secured an order of the Federal High Court, Abuja to stop the EFCC from further investigation of the matter.
But dissatisfied, the EFCC approached the Abuja Division of the Court of Appeal and asked it to set aside the decision of the Federal High Court and allow its investigation against the company to continue.
The Appeal Court upheld the EFCC’s appeal, and directed the anti-graft agency to continue with its investigation of the company.
Displeased with the Appeal Court’s decision, Yanaty moved to the Supreme Court and urged it to shield it from further investigation by the EFCC.
However, when the case came up on Wednesday, October 4, 2017, Counsel to Yanaty, Bolaji Ayorinde, SAN, in his argument, said that as long as Yanaty is concerned, investigations on the payment of Fuel Subsidies by the EFCC or any agency has been concluded.
Ayorinde also said that his client had been cleared through investigation by the Committee on Verification and Reconciliation of Fuel Subsidy and therefore submitted that Yanaty cannot be reinvestigated on the same allegation.
He therefore prayed for an order restraining the EFCC, their servants, agents or representatives or any agency from carrying out any investigation, interrogation or inviting the plaintiff on anything related to fraud and money laundering.

But in his response, Counsel to the EFCC, Sylvanus Tahir, urged the court to dismiss the appellant’s appeal and sustain the judgment of the Court of Appeal and also prayed the Court to order the appellant to submit itself to the EFCC to clear the allegations made against Yanaty Petrochemical Ltd.

Tahir further said that another fallacy by Yanaty is the baseless and repeated claims that it was given a clean bill of health by the Presidential Committee on Verification and Reconciliation of Fuel Subsidy Payments.

According to Tahir; “It is far from the truth and attempt to twist the report of the t Committee. Investigation into Yanaty Petrochemical Ltd by EFCC dates back to 2012 from the fallout of ‘Occupy’ Nigeria when EFCC received petitions against several oil marketing companies and importers for alleged over bloating of fuel subsidy.”

In its considered judgment, the panel of five justices led by Justice Inyang Okoro held that “the appeal is unmeritorious” and accordingly dismissed it.

Leave a comment

Related Articles

NDLEA busts N22.74bln Opioids at Lagos, Port Harcourt ports

Operatives of the National Drug Law Enforcement Agency (NDLEA) have seized large...

Horrific! Hubby stabs fatally newlywed wife, sets house on fire in Lagos

In a fit of rage, 30-year-old Motunrayo Olaniyi has allegedly stabbed his...

In Lagos, man arrested for stabbing father to death

Chibunnma Chimelie, a 25-year-old man, has been arrested for fatally stabbing his...

Unleashing of wild dogs on police: 2 people remanded in prison, face life imprisonment

For allegedly unleashing four wild dogs on police to obstruct the arrest...

Police take into custody suspected killer of abducted FUNAAB female student

The Lagos State Police Command says it has taken over the case...

Four arrested for blackmailing ex-NPA MD, posing as EFCC officials

Four suspects have been arrested by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission...

UK court sentences four Nigerians for fake marriage certificate scheme

For creating fake marriage certificates that allowed Nigerians to live illegally in...

Display of Russian flag: Kano Police Command transfers 76 suspects to Abuja

The Kano State Police Command has handed over 76 people, including a...

At last, NDLEA nabs long-sought Lagos drug cartel leader

The National Drug Law Enforcement Agency (NDLEA) said on Wednesday that its...

NDLEA uncovers hard drugs hidden in incense candles, women’s clothing in Lagos

Operatives of the National Drug Law Enforcement Agency (NDLEA) in Lagos have...

NDLEA seizes codeine shipments worth N9.8bn from India

The National Drug Law Enforcement Agency (NDLEA) announced on Friday that its...

Updated: Gambaryan case: Court orders arrest of Kuje prison medical doctor

A Federal High Court in Abuja has ordered the arrest of Dr....

Court declines Emefiele’s request to travel abroad for medical checkup

A Federal High Court in Maitama, Abuja, on Tuesday rejected an application...

Blord, crypto mogul, arrested by police for suspected fraud and terrorism ties

Linus Williams, a.k.a. BLord, a prominent cryptocurrency entrepreneur, was taken into custody...

Just in: Buhari’s Power Minister, Mamman, gets reprieve, N10bln bail

A Federal High Court in Abuja on Friday granted bail to former...

Updated: Ex-Power minister remanded in prison over alleged N33bn fraud

A Federal High Court in Abuja has remanded Saleh Mamman, a former...

Counterfeit alcoholic beverages: NAFDAC seals 100 shops, suspects apprehended in Enugu

The National Agency for Food Drug Administration and Control (NAFDAC) has shut...

Customs busts 10 containers laden with illegal arms, drugs in Port Harcourt

The Nigeria Customs Service has made a significant bust at Onne Port...

12 Ajayi Crowther University students cleared of murder charges

An Iyaganku Chief Magistrates’ Court in Ibadan, Oyo State capital, on Monday...