Reuben Abati 
Columnist

Understanding APC and the crisis of defections by Reuben Abati

102

Comrade Adams Oshiomhole, the “factional” leader of the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC) has reportedly asked Senate President Abubakar Bukola Saraki to resign his position as Senate President.  What exactly does the Comrade want Saraki to resign from- the Senate Presidency or even his membership of the Senate having won election into the Assembly in the first place on the platform of the APC? Oshiomhole also probably expects that other members of the APC who are occupying elective and appointive positions will also tender letters of resignation, having defected from the ruling APC.

 

It is either the embattled party Chairman has not adverted his mind to the provisions of the Nigerian Constitution on party matters or the party’s legal adviser is not doing his job.  The gale of defections from the ruling APC  – 16 Senators, including the Senate President, three Governors, 37 members of the House of Representatives, the Nigerian Ambassador to South Africa, the National Publicity Secretary of the APC, and looks like more to come in the days ahead, including Ministers who may be preparing their letters of resignation, their political principals having deserted the party – raises a number of questions, political, moral and legal.  I intend to address some of these in order to assist the leaders of the APC to stop acting as cry-babies and to attempt a clarification of the nature and character of the tsunami that seems now certain, if unchecked, to sweep the APC out of power.

 

With regard to the Saraki defection, the language of the Constitution is very clear and specific in Section 50(1) (a) wherein it is stated that there shall be “a President and a Deputy President of the Senate, who shall be elected by the members of the House from among themselves”. The same expression is retained in Section 50 (1)(b) as applicable to the House of Representatives, and the emphasis is on the phrase – “from among themselves.” The Constitution thus does not say that the Senate President or the Speaker and their Deputies must come from the ruling or majority party; indeed any of the members of the Assembly can occupy the mentioned positions once their colleagues choose them “from among themselves.” Saraki does not therefore have to resign his Senate Presidency because he has left the APC, that party also cannot order him to resign.  The only way he or the Speaker of the House of Representatives can be removed is stated in Section 50 of the Constitution and in the present circumstance Section 50(2)(c) is of particular interest – it prescribes removal only “by the votes of not less than two-thirds majority of the members of that House”.

 

Can the APC at the moment muster up to “two-thirds majority” in either the Red or the Green Chamber to remove the Senate President or the Speaker and their Deputies? I don’t think so. There are probably more persons in both Houses who have also resolved to defect from the APC but who are still physically identifying with the party in order to stay behind as fifth columnists, or simply because of a lingering lack of clarity about their fortunes in their local political environments should they defect at a wrong time.

 

I think Comrade Oshiomhole also needs to be reminded that Nigeria is not running a parliamentary system; the agenda of party supremacy that he has been pushing, and which probably makes him sound like a cane-welding party chairman – dishing out Stalin-like instructions to other party members, is only bound to alienate others, and effectively turn him into an undertaker. A Constitutional democracy such as we run requires greater inclusion, horse-trading and statesmanship rather than the dominant rhetoric of arrogance.

 

Those who have defected from the APC also need not lose any sleep, particularly members of the legislative houses. Specifically, Section 68 of the 1999 Constitution outlines the circumstances under which a member of the Senate or House of Representatives shall vacate his seat; the most relevant to this commentary being Section 68 (1) (g) which permits defections from one political party to the other in the event of a division in the political party of which a person is a member, or the merger of two or more political parties or factions. Those APC members who are protesting the defection of the Senate President and others cannot deny that there is a division within the APC or that the party is now divided into factions – the Oshiomhole-led faction, the Engr. Buba Galadima-led faction better known as the Reformed APC and the Saraki faction, which has now returned to the PDP.

 

However, whereas Section 68(1) (g) offers such protection to defecting members of the National Assembly, the Nigerian Constitution is silent on the matter of Governors who come to power and office on the platform of one political party and who while still in office choose to cross to another political party.  This is the dilemma that is thrown up by the phrasing of Section 221, and perhaps the basis for Oshimohole’s request for Saraki’s resignation, even if the provision does not apply to him in the light of a reading of other sections. Section 221 states that:  “No association, other than a political party shall canvass for votes for any candidate at any election or contribute to the funds of any political party or to the election expenses of any candidate at an election.”

 

In other words, for the purposes of elections, the Constitution recognizes only political parties as the vehicle through which any candidate may seek elective office.  In the absence of any provision for independent candidacy, nobody can seek office except through a political party, and hence the votes belong to the party and not the individual. It is political parties that canvass for votes. The Governor or rather the candidate is therefore a trustee of the party. The question then is: can a trustee run away with the fundamental object of the trust, namely the position that he occupies? If and when he does so, it will appear that he has shortchanged his political party and the electorate.

 

The only way to determine this, however, is through the court of law, and not the kind of self-help tactics that the APC seems to prefer. There have been reports that some members of the Senate are plotting to take over the National Assembly and Nicodemously impeach Senator Bukola Saraki. The leadership of the APC is advised to commit to due process, and not to encourage any illegal conduct. In Benue state, the Governor, Samuel Ortom has also complained that he is being harassed, and there has been an attempt by eight out of the 30 members of the State House of Assembly to impeach the Governor. The matter is now before the court.

 

The level of persecution, harassment and injury to character over the matter of defections from the APC is most strange. After all, the APC itself was a beneficiary of a similar development in 2013-2014, when members of the new PDP and APGA defected from their parties to join the APC coalition. Aminu Tambuwal, then Speaker of the House of Representatives received fulsome praise from then Presidential candidate Muhammadu Buhari for leading many PDP lawmakers to join the APC.  Comrade Adams Oshiomhole also deployed his “eloquence” to encourage members of the PDP to join the APC. Since the APC got to power in 2015, many more members of the PDP have defected to the ruling party. APC leaders did not see anything wrong in this; they did not accuse the defecting PDP members of anti-party activities, so why should they complain now that they are being served a dose of their own medicine? Or are there other issues, within the ruling party, such as post-2015 financial reconciliation or the sharing of spoils, that the public needs to know so that we can be better informed?

 

I say this because when you read the statements that have been made by those who have just defected from the party, you can only but be shocked. Engr. Galadima who was a major engineer of the 2015 APC victory is now engineering contempt and odium against the party. Governor Ortom has pointed to a failure of leadership within the party. Governor Tambuwal sounded very harsh as he talked about corruption, mismanagement of the economy, the spread of national insecurity and what he calls “prison-yard democracy.”  The former APC National Publicity Secretary, Bolaji Abdullahi also issued a statement dripping with venom and contempt for a political party, which he had defended only a week earlier.  Saraki’s anger is perhaps on the face of it, understandable – here was a man who from day one was not given any respite by the Buhari Presidency, here was a man who was criminalised by the same party he helped to build; he had to be saved by the Supreme Court of Nigeria, only to be labeled “an armed robber” subsequently.  Like Saul on the way to Damascus, Saraki and others have now seen the light; like the Biblical prodigal son, they are all returning to the PDP, which Dino Melaye calls their “home”. It took the People’s Democratic Party (PDP) 16 years to implode; it has taken the APC less than four years to reach the same point.

 

In 2014, the PDP was divided, and confused as to how to handle the same situation such as this that has now arisen with the APC. There were members of the party who advised that the then Attorney General of the Federation should be asked to take the defecting five Governors of the time to court, and if that would be a long process, the President should declare a state of emergency in the affected states and have the Governors removed or impeached and sole administrators appointed in their place. Mohammed Bello Adoke, AGF and Minister of Justice, as he then was, insisted that it was not the duty of his office to dabble into partisan politics and that if anybody should go to court, it should be the political party, the owner of the trust in contention and not the Federal Government of Nigeria. The party didn’t want to go to court. It wanted the five Governors punished.  The President didn’t buy into their idea.

 

Those whose views prevailed eventually were those who argued that the five Governors could go if they wanted. They said it was God himself cleansing the party by removing the bad eggs within. They were sure that the defection of the Governors and some members of the National Assembly would not affect the party in any way in the 2015 general elections.  As we all know, the PDP paid dearly for this. The APC is about to suffer the same fate.  Oshiomhole Is not helping matters with his rhetoric. The President is also aloof. He went to inspect the campaign headquarters for his re-election bid and then jetted off to London for a 10-day vacation. If I were in President Buhari’s shoes, I would not consider this a right time to go on vacation.  He would have nobody to blame if by the time he returns, there have been more defections from his party and government.

 

The situation is more worrisome moreso as the President, realizing the brewing crisis within the party, a few months ago, set up a Reconciliation Committee led by the party’s national leader, Asiwaju Bola Ahmed Tinubu. What happened to that Reconciliation Committee?  Did it ever submit any report? And if it did, who and who did it reconcile?  It is quite curious that in the face of the on-going crisis within the APC, Asiwaju Bola Tinubu, the Chairman of the Presidential Reconciliation Committee has been silent. His silence is too pregnant with meaning. Is it a cautious admission of the failure of the Committee he led, or an admission that the crisis is not resolvable?

 

In all of this, we are left with two things. The first is that our politicians are not principled at all. They can belong to the PDP in the morning, the APC by noon and within 24 hours, they could join a completely new party and advance strong arguments to justify their nomadism. The political parties are not built on any concrete principles or ideology either; they are vehicles for political survival and access to power by ambitious politicians. The second thing is that we, the people, are the ones who are short-changed. By now, governance has more or less stopped within Nigeria’s ruling party; the politics of 2019 has taken over. Bad politics results in bad economics and the crisis of growth and progress. With a National Assembly that has suspended key legislative work, and an Executive that is seeking a second term in office, and whose President is on holiday, while the party is on fire, international investors have also put Final Investment Decisions on hold, the market is in the grips of uncertainty, GDP ratings are stagnant, creeping stasis is imminent, and all of that, until Nigeria’s political drama is resolved. The only thing that is not on hold is the people’s frustration and the rising cost of being Nigerian.

Leave a comment

Recent Posts

I started creating content at age 9 – Layi Wasabi …….I felt I needed a tour guide for Anikulapo’s set- Layi Wasabi From making funny skits on Instagram to appearing in Kunle Afolayan’s blockbuster movie, Anikulapo, Olayiwola Isaac, popularly known as Layi Wasabi, is making efforts to keep exploring the entertainment industry. In this interview with DAVID ADEBAYO, Layi shares his journey into skit-making, acting, and more that should be expected from him. PSN: You became popular with skit making, and suddenly, you are in the face of everybody. Now everybody wants to see you beyond Instagram. You have transitioned into acting, and it seems you started on the right footing with Anikulapo. Does your quickness surprise you? Layi: Okay, let me describe the feeling like this: You know, when you’re a child and you put your leg into your father’s shoes, you know you will walk around in those shoes, feeling funny and wobbling. That was how being on the Anikulapo set felt to me. It was a huge leap. It also made me question whether I was prepared to tackle the show. For the longest time, I’ve always been a lover of theatre. I’ve always wanted to do movies, stage performances, and even stand-up comedy. I just wanted to entertain in every dramatic form. PSN: Did you ever think Anikulapo would bring you to the limelight? I didn’t think that Anikulapo would be one of my first movies as Layi Wasabi. So when I got the call from the director that I was part of the cast for Anikulapo, it was a thrilling experience. PSN: It is one thing that you’re called to be on the set of Anikulapo; it’s another thing to have the idea that it is being pushed by Netflix; what was that feeling like? Layi: For me, I think Netflix came as an afterthought. So I think the first thing that came to mind, aside from the sponsor, was the project itself. So, knowing that Netflix is there lets you know the level at which the production of this movie is going to be. And that, for me, is super amazing. You know that this is a large scale and a very hyper-genre. But for me, what struck me first as an actor was what I had to do to get the art form at its best. I knew Kunle Afolayan was someone who was very committed to art. Therefore, someone of Kunle Afolayan’s calibre would expect you to give your utmost interpretation in whatever role he assigns you. PSN: So you felt you had to bring your A-game into this? Layi: So first of all, I knew that I was on his set with Kunle Afolayan; that was the first thing on my mind. Then I told myself, Layi, you have to bring your A game to this thing. Then, as I was working on a Netflix project, it dawned on me that it was indeed a Netflix project. I thought, Okay, this is serious business, boy; you have to do what you’re doing right. Yeah, some people were expecting to see the green lace and the green cocktail, just like you do on Instagram. PSN: Were you overwhelmed at any point? Layi: It was simply a dream-like situation for me. That was how it felt. I felt like a kid in a museum. That’s how it feels. I remember the first time I saw Taiwo Hassan. He passed me, and I felt like I grew up watching the people I was on set with. I felt like I needed a tour guide on that set. It was a huge moment in my life. So it was a dreamlike experience, very humbling, and very inspiring. PSN: What do you think about the storyline that you played in? Layi:It was a role that was offered, but I kind of understood why the casting director would pick me for the role. You know, and the two other people that, cause, the role I was supposed to play was that of someone that was pestering Saro. So, I could understand why the casting director was picking me for the role. The casting director decided to pick people like Wasabi, Sisi Quadri, may God rest his soul, and Funmi Awelewa for that role because, if you’re familiar with things that we’ve done aside from this project, you know that we know how to lambast people with our words. PSN: You have been nominated for the African Magic Viewers Choice Award (AMVCA); how does it feel to be recognized for your creative work? Layi: I’m grateful to God for life. I’m also grateful to African Magic and MultiChoice for the opportunity and the recognition, as a lot of work goes into digital content creation, and it is gratifying to have my work listed as something worth this honour. PSN: Can you tell us about your journey as a content creator and how you got started in this field? Layi: My journey as a content creator has pretty much been jet fuel. Although I’ve been doing content creation since I was about 9–10, I’ve also been acting since I was 13. Content creation for the digital space started in 2021, and there were a few challenges here and there, but overall, it’s been an amazing experience. I was able to gather an audience quite quickly. It came with a few challenges, but the upsides are better than the downsides. PSN: What inspires you to create content, and where do you draw your creative inspiration from? Layi: What inspired me to create content was the opportunity to share jokes and ideas. I’ve always been someone who loves social gatherings for the opportunity to just tell stories and share jokes with friends. Creating content felt like a way to do that. PSN: What do you consider to be your unique style or niche as a content creator? Layi: I think I create content for different purposes. Some of the content I create is for entertainment, and some is for people to relate to. My shooting star, POP, features a single man in front of the camera, while the content behind the camera is a blend of various styles. I really don’t know if there’s a niche in the comedy genre. I just feel like I create content for a particular purpose, or one that I have in mind at the time. PSN:How do you stay motivated and overcome creative blocks or challenges in your work? Layi: What motivates me the most is my audience; it’s very motivating to see the pool of people who didn’t know you before or haven’t met in real life just rooting for you, hoping to see you win, and looking forward to what you want to do next. It’s a very motivating feeling, and I love how I overcome creative blocks; sometimes I just step back from the drawing board and just experience life a little bit. I might as well grab a book and read or watch a movie. That’s the process of overcoming creative blocks for me. PSN: Can you walk us through your creative process, from idea generation to final execution? Layi: I think it differs from idea to idea. Some ideas originate as complete concepts, encompassing the beginning of the concept and its intended conclusion. The only thing I would do as a creative sometimes is just build the dialogue and the acting it would require. For some ideas, it could take months or weeks to have a perfect ending to the beginning of the story. It differs. In situations like that, ideas that don’t come as finished thoughts have to focus on the ones that are almost complete or finished already. Sometimes I revisit the old ones that I’ve not completed. I don’t force it most of the time. PSN: What advice would you give to aspiring content creators who are looking to establish themselves in the industry? Layi: They should try out a number of things and stick to what they know how to do best and what they think will make their audience thrive. Do what you are most comfortable doing as a content creator, because at the end of the day, if you are not comfortable doing that kind of content, at some point you will feel the need to outgrow it. It is important for a content creator to have a niche in order to grow your audience more strategically. PSN: How do you use social media and online platforms to engage with your audience and grow your content creator brand? Layi: It’s important for a content creator to grow a significant amount of following, and not just that, but a following that you understand. If you understand how to navigate your audience and have amassed a significant amount of it, this is what builds your influence as a brand and a content creator. That’s how I try to leverage social media by understanding my audience and trying to expand the reach I have as a content creator. PSN: Do you see yourself winning the AMVCA Award? Layi: It’s a privilege to be nominated. I hope I’m able to win, and I also recognize the fact that I’m shortlisted among great people, but it will be a pleasure. I would lie if I said I had not pictured myself winning the award, but it’s a pleasure to be nominated and recognized for the honour of winning an AMVCA.

Related Articles

Fuel Subsidy And The God Of Jonathan

by Reuben Abati One of the first things that had been cited...

More Notes On The Elections

by Reuben Abati The prevalence of the comic spirit is one of...

Nigeria: February 25 And The Aftermath

by Reuben Abati Nigeria held its Presidential and National Assembly elections on...

Nigeria 2023: The Best And Worst Of Times

by Reuben Abati The best way to describe what has happened to...

The Chatham House Effect

by Reuben Abati There seems to be a scramble, a rush, by...

2022: A Year In Review

by Reuben Abati   By this time next week, the year 2022...

The Vice President as a Salesman

By ETIM ETIM In the immediate aftermath of the APC presidential primary...

Osinbajo’s investment pitch and the new vista for Nigeria

Vice President Yemi Osinbajo has proven on many occasions, to be the...

Nigeria: Who is in Charge?

By Reuben Abati Just recently, President Muhammadu Buhari travelled out of the...

‘Putin’ the cart before the horse in Ukraine

By Olukayode Oyeleye Russia’s president, Vladimir Putin, is clearly now at his...

Africa and Climate Change – A Conversation with US Senator John Kerry towards COP27

By Tony O. Elumelu As the world continues to experience the daily...

ASUU, Inflation, Monkey Pox and Other Problems

By Reuben Abati   “Ko ko Ko.  Pon Pon, Pon. . Helloo...

NBC’s sledgehammer to democracy and media rights

By Emmanuel Ogbeche The buzz is still building and the apprehension in...

William Ruto And Kenya Election

By Reuben Abati And thus, it is done: the people of the...

Nigeria: More Universities Where?

by Reuben Abati I stumbled on a story in the Nigerian media...

Rebellion At the Apex Court

By Reuben Abati “Wahala be like bicycle” is an expression that most...

Hero-Worshipping Senator Ajibola Basiru’s Agbada Caught in a Barbwire

This is a rejoinder to Senator Ajibola Basiru’s piece titled “Osinbajo: Senator...

Goldmine Season For Lawyers

by  Reuben Abati It is a goldmine season for Nigerian lawyers, mealtime,...

Osinbajo’s world-class declaration speech

In the digital age of technology and social media and metaverse, it...