PoliticsTop Story

Supreme Court to determine Omo-Agege/Emerhor’s fate

121

The lingering legal tussle over the leadership of the All Progressives Congress (APC) in Delta State has moved to the Supreme Court as the Chief Cyril Ogodo led leadership of the party has asked the apex court to set aside the judgment of the Court of Appeal which had sacked it and reinstated Jones Erue leadership as the Executive Committee of the party in the State.

Specifically the Court of Appeal had in a judgment delivered by Justice Jimi Olukayode Bada, Chidi Nwaoma Uwa and Muhammed L.Shuaibu on May 19th set aside the Judgment of the Federal High Court Asaba Division which had upheld the Ogodo led Executive Committee as the authentic leadership of the party in Delta State.

It would be recalled that the Federal High Court, Asaba Division, had on March 18th sacked the Jones Erue-led executive of the party in Delta State. The court had also voided the participation of Senator Ovie Omo Agege and Chief Great Ogboru as the All Progressive Congress (APC) candidates in the 2019 elections in Delta.

O’tega-Emerhor

 

The court’s decision followed the case filed by the Cyril Ogodo-led faction of the party, urging the court to recognize it as the authentic APC executive in Delta State. The Ogodo-led faction had also urged the court to sack the Erue-led executive which produced Mr Omo Agege and Mr Ogboru as the party’s candidates.

The court in it judgement similarly upheld the full template of the Ogodo faction’s candidates, including Dr. Pat Utomi, O’tega Emerhor and Ima Niboro as the party’s authentic candidates in the just concluded elections.

The Ogodo faction fielded Mr Emerhor for the Delta Central Senatorial District election and Mr Niboro for the Ughelli North/South/Udu Federal Constituency seat in the House of Representatives.

However not satisfied the Erue led faction of the party and the Indepedent National Electoral Commission (INEC) had gone to the Court of Appeal to challenge the decision of the lower court and the Court of Appeal in a unanimous decision allowed the appeal and restored the Erue led leadership on the grounds that the matter was filed out of time and therefore statute barred.

In the unanimous judgment delivered on March 17th and read by Justice Chidi Nwaoma Uwa the court held that the lower court lacked jurisdiction to entertain the suit as it bordered on an intra-party matter.

The court stated that the failure of the respondents to file their suit within 14 days of the issue complained of (pre-election) extinguished their rights.

But in a swift reaction, the Ogodo led State Executive Committee of the party through their Counsel O.J Oghenejakpor in an appeal at the Supreme Court asked the apex court to set aside the judgment of the Appellate Court on the grounds that the Justices of the Court of Appeal erred in law when they held that the appellants have abandoned their preliminary objection and thereby refused to entertain the preliminary objection properly raised before them and ended up striking same out without considering it.

The appellants also contended that the Justices of the Court of Appeal misdirected themselves in law in their consideration of the cause of action of the appellants when they held in pages 17-18 of the judgment in part thus”it is clear that the crux of the suit at the lower court is the status of the Executive of 4th respondent (APC) at the State,Later cal Government and Wards levels in Delta State.

“The positions sought to be declared as authentic, legal and valid are various levels of political party (4th respondent and 1st defendant at the trial) officials in Delta State. It is not a suit in respect of the selection or nomination of a candidate of a political party for election who were to be sponsored by the 4th respondent. It is a case purely concerning members of the State Executives of the 4th respondent in Delta State”.

The appellants further averted that their claim as disclosed from the record of appeal was a complaint against the breach of the APC Constitution, APC guidelines for the conduct of primaries, Electoral Act 2010(as amended) and the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 by the respondents which has vested them with a cause of action.

The appellants further contended that the lower court by limiting its consideration to reliefs 1-6 of the statement of claim amounted to a denial of fair hearing.

They stated that the lower court took a one sided view of the case and ignored to positively look at the case of the appellants and the findings of the Federal High Court made in respect of the issues placed before the trial court.

The appellants maintained that the Court of Appeal erred in law when they entertained the appeal of the 1st respondent and allowed even when the 1st respondent failed to lead any evidence at the trail court in support of The averments contained in its statement of defence.

They asked the apex court to allow the appeal in its entirety, an order setting aside the judgment of the Court of Appeal including the order as to costs and and order affirming the judgment of the Trail Court

Leave a comment

Related Articles

Bello withdrew $720,000 from state account for his children’s school fees – EFCC Chair Olukoyede

Ex-governor of Kogi State, Mr. Yahaya Bello, withdrew $720,000 from the state...

Just in: EFCC arrests Ex-Aviation Minister Sirika over alleged N8bln fraud

The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission has arrested former Minister of Aviation,...

Just in: Reps ex-Deputy Speaker Ihedioha quits PDP

The main opposition party, the People’s Democratic Party (PDP), has lost another...

Breaking: Dana airline crash lands in Lagos 

A Dana airline has crash-landed at the Murtala Muhammed International Airport, Ikeja....

Regional counter-terrorism centre for intelligence sharing, operational coordination, a must – Tinubu

President Bola Tinubu made a case on Monday for the establishment of...

Fleeing Binance executive arrested in Kenya, faces extraction to Nigeria this week

Kenyan police authorities have reportedly apprehended Mr. Nadeem Anjarwalla, an executive associated...

Aiyedatiwa declared winner of Ondo APC governorship primary, gives acceptance speech

Gov. Lucky Aiyedatiwa of Ondo State has won the ticket of the...

Tinubu opens African Counter-Terrorism Summit in Abuja on April 22

President Bola Tinubu will open the African Counter-Terrorism Summit on Monday, April...

APC declares Ondo governorship primary inconclusive

In Ondo State, the All Progressives Congress (APC) 2024 Governorship Primary Committee...

Ondo APC guber primary: 171,922 delegates elect candidate out of 16 aspirants

No fewer than 171,922 accredited delegates are voting in Saturday’s All Progressives...

Breaking: Nigerian chess master Tunde Onakoya breaks world record for longest chess marathon

The Nigerian chess master, Tunde Onakoya, has set a new Guinness World...

Update: Nigeria Immigration Service has put former Gov. Yahaya Bello on the watchlist

More woes for the former Kogi State Governor, Mr. Yahaya Bello, as...

Tinubu directs overhaul of nation’s tiers of education system

President Bola Tinubu has approved the comprehensive overhaul of Nigeria’s educational system...

PDP Chair Umar Damagum survives sack plot

Amb. Umar Damagum, the Acting National Chairman of the People’s Democratic Party...

PDP NWC passes confidence vote in acting national chair Damagun amid calls for his resignation

Amid calls for his resignation and ahead of the 98th National Executive...

EFCC operatives allegedly barricade ex-Kogi Gov. Yahaya Bello’s Abuja residence

Operatives of the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) have allegedly barricaded...

Cubana Chief Priest arraigned in Lagos, gets N10m bail after pleading not guilty

Businessman and socialite, Pascal Okechukwu, popularly known as Cubana Chief Priest, was...

Pres. Tinubu launches National Single Window project, to generate annual $2.7bln revenue

“This initiative will link our ports, government agencies and key stakeholders, creating...

FG has rescued over 1,000 abductees without ransom payment — NSA Ribadu

The National Security Adviser, retired AIG Nuhu Ribadu, says the Federal Government...